“Maybe we shouldn’t sell after all,” Vernon said, while the realtor was still waiting for an answer about the buyers’ offer.

I had the paper with the offer on my lap. We’d both signed it the night before. Six months of open houses, strangers looking in our closets, and wiping the same kitchen counter before every showing. I looked past him at the garage door. Half the garage was packed.

“You said yes,” I told him.

“I know what I said.”

He didn’t look at me. That bothered me more than the change of mind. Vernon had packed his fishing rods, his old boots, and the tackle box he’d had since before we married. I’d thought it meant we were finally getting somewhere. We’d been talking about moving closer to the coast for thirty-two years.

The realtor, Paula, was quiet on the phone. I told her I’d call back. Then I asked Vernon what had changed.

“The buyers are moving too fast,” he said.

That didn’t make sense. We’d accepted their offer. They had an inspection scheduled. Vernon had spent weeks telling me he was ready to be done with the house. I knew he was tired of the stairs and the yard. I also knew the garage didn’t pack itself.

“I thought this was what we wanted,” I said.

He rubbed his thumb over a spot on the table. “I need to think.”

He had been thinking for years. That was the problem.

We had a long-running argument that didn’t sound like an argument if you heard only the polite version.

I wanted to stay near our children and grandchildren. Vernon wanted the coast. He talked about the wind, the fishing, the quiet. I talked about Sunday dinners and school concerts and being close enough to help when somebody needed us.

Neither of us was wrong, exactly. But we kept bringing it up and never making a choice. Our kids grew up. They had families of their own. Still, I could find a reason to stay another year. Vernon could find a reason to go another summer.

Six months ago, when we decided to list the house, I took that as a real decision. I pictured us finding a smaller place and splitting the difference. Maybe not right on the coast, but close enough that he could fish and I could still drive to see the grandkids. I thought we were finally making a plan together.

I wanted that so much I didn’t ask many questions.

After Vernon changed his mind, I went out to the garage. I told myself I was checking what still needed packing.

The truth is, I wanted to see whether he was scared of the move or hiding something from me.

I found the tackle box under a folded tarp. It was dusty, and the metal latch stuck when I tried to open it. I had to press down with my palm. Inside were a few lures, an old fishing license, and a bundle of postcards held together with a rubber band.

They were all from Maine. Same small coastal address on the back. Four years of dates. None had a stamp.

I don’t know why I remember the smell of the rubber band. Old and a little sour. I do remember it.

Vernon had gone fishing by himself a few times over the years. He’d say he needed a couple days, and I’d let him go. I didn’t love it, but I understood wanting some quiet. I didn’t know he’d been going to Maine.

His calendar had no trips marked there. His stories were always about the fish, or the drive, or how bad the coffee was.

I carried the postcards inside.

He was still in the living room, sitting on the edge of the chair. I set the bundle between us.

“Tell me what these are.”

His eyes went to the cards. He didn’t pick them up.

“Where did you get those?”

“In your tackle box. They’re all from Maine.”

He kept looking at them. “I was going to tell you.”

“When?”

“I don’t know.”

I felt silly asking that, but I did anyway. “Were you planning to leave me?”

He finally looked at me. “I was trying to decide whether to take you with me.”

That was the sentence. I heard it, but my mind went to the offer paper on my lap, to the packed garage, to all those years I thought we were having the same conversation.

“What does that mean, Vernon?”

He pressed both hands together. “I found a place up there. A little cottage.”

“You bought a house?”

“No. I rented it when I went. I went back every year.”

“For four years?”

He nodded.

I wanted to yell. I wanted to ask why he had let me talk about grandkids and moving plans while he had already pictured a different life. Instead I said, “You went there without telling me.”

“I know.”

“Were you going to leave?”

“I thought about it.”

He said it quietly. Not as a threat. That almost made it worse.

Then he told me about the health scare. Four years earlier, he’d had chest pain while working in the garage. It passed, and he went to the clinic the next morning. The tests were fine. The doctor told him to take it easy for a while. Vernon never told me how scared he’d been.

“I was tired,” he said. “I kept thinking I’d spend my whole life saying maybe later.”

“So you started planning to go without me?”

“I didn’t know what else to do.”

There was the answer, or part of one. Vernon thought I would never leave our children’s orbit. He thought I would say no before he had to ask. Maybe he was right. Maybe I’d given him enough reasons to think that.

But he hadn’t asked.

I have my own part in this. I could make family plans sound like they were set in stone. I’d say I couldn’t leave because of a birthday or a school play, and then I’d say we could talk about it later. Later was a nice word. It let me sound open without changing anything.

Still, I hadn’t been writing postcards to a place where I might live alone. He had.

I picked up one card. The front showed a gray strip of water and a row of small buildings. The back had no message, only a date and that Maine address. I turned it over twice, like there might be a second side I’d missed.

The realtor called again. Vernon flinched at the sound, then looked at me.

“Don’t answer yet,” he said.

I did answer. Paula asked whether the buyers could go ahead with the inspection the next morning. I looked at Vernon, then at the unsigned paperwork on the side table.

“I’m stopping the sale,” I said. “Please tell them we’re withdrawing.”

Paula asked if I was sure. I said yes.

There was a pause. She told me the buyers wouldn’t be happy, and the agency might have paperwork to sort out. I said I understood. I did not say I was sorry. Not then.

When I hung up, Vernon stood up.

“You didn’t have to do that.”

“Yes, I did.”

“The buyers, ”

“They can be mad. They made a fair offer. I’m the one who told Paula to stop it.”

He lowered himself back into the chair. I could tell he wanted to explain, but he’d used up his easy explanations.

The next few weeks were awkward. Paula had to call the buyers and go over the withdrawal. We had some forms to sign and a fee to settle. The house stayed ours. We were still living in it, with half the garage in boxes and no agreement about where we’d go.

That part looked like a reprieve. For a little while, I could pretend the house was the only problem. We had stopped the sale. Vernon was home. I could see the grandkids when I wanted. Nothing had been decided.

But the postcards were still on the table.

I asked him to tell me everything about the trips. Not because I wanted to hear how pretty the water was. I wanted to know what he had done when he got there, what he pictured, what he was afraid to say at home.

He told me about the cottage, a small place near the shore. He said he liked that nobody there knew him as a father or a grandfather or the man who fixed the sticking back door. He could get up, fish, eat something, and not have to explain himself.

I understood that. I didn’t like it, but I understood it.

Then he said, “I thought you’d be happier here.”

“Here where?”

“Near the kids.”

“I am happy near them.”

He nodded, as if that proved his point.

“I’m also your wife,” I said. “You could’ve asked what I wanted.”

“I thought I knew.”

“You didn’t.”

He didn’t argue. That was the first useful thing he’d done in days.

I told him I wasn’t going to move to Maine just because he’d already picked out a place. I also wasn’t going to stay here forever because I was afraid of missing a Sunday dinner. I needed him to stop making a private plan and calling it a choice he was giving me.

“I won’t do that again,” he said.

“You can’t promise what you’ll want.”

“I can promise to tell you.”

It wasn’t enough to make me trust him right away. I told him that, too.

We sat at the kitchen table the next afternoon and talked about what happened next. Not where we would live. Not yet. We agreed to keep the house for now, and to stop treating “for now” like an answer that could last forever. We would talk about Maine, the kids, the money, and what each of us wanted without pretending that wanting one thing meant we didn’t love the other.

Vernon said he wanted to keep going to the coast.

I said I might want to go with him sometimes. I also said I might not. He had to be able to hear that without turning my answer into a reason to leave me out.

“I can hear it,” he said.

I hope he can. I’m not sure yet.

The postcards were still there. I spread them across the scarred wooden table, not to forgive him and not to throw them away. Outside, the afternoon sun dipped behind the familiar neighborhood rooftops. For once, neither of us called that a decision.