I had Thistle’s head in my lap on the dirt floor, and Aaron was running for warm water. She was the little brown-and-white goat with the crooked horn, the one I’d seen eat a purple thistle at the stockyard that afternoon. Her breath came in short pulls. Aaron looked at her thin sides and said, “Margaret, I don’t think she’s going to make it.” I was afraid he was right, but I had learned to check before I gave up.
I felt her hard flanks move under my hand. Her udder was swollen, too. That was when I understood the trouble wasn’t some sickness spreading through the herd. Thistle was trying to give birth, and the trip had started her labor before she was ready. The way it happened that night is the reason I still think of that hillside differently, even after all these years.
Six years earlier, Aaron and I had taken up forty rocky acres in Bitter Creek Valley, Colorado. The cabin leaked when it rained, the soil was thin, and the slopes were too steep for cattle. Howell Briggs, the richest cattleman in the valley, wanted our land for its runoff rights. He kept making offers. I kept saying no.
That answer got harder to hold onto every year. Aaron worked from sunup until his hands cracked, then came in and looked across at Briggs’s green pastures.
I knew what he was thinking, because I thought it too. If we had a good dairy cow, maybe all that work would finally amount to something. But a decent cow cost nearly twice what we had, and our hillside barely grew grass.
My mother had made butter and cheese in Wisconsin. She taught me to keep a clean pail, watch the milk, and not rush a batch just because I was tired. I didn’t know yet whether any of that would help us in Colorado. Mostly, I knew how little we had left.
That summer the drought got worse. The grass in even Briggs’s pastures turned yellow, so Aaron heard about an auction at Caldwell’s stockyard and asked me to come along. I agreed because I could see he needed something to hope for. We had thirty-one dollars between us.
Briggs was near the auction ring when we arrived, laughing with a group of ranchers.
He looked Aaron up and down. “Looking for livestock, Doyle, or just admiring animals you can’t afford?” Aaron lowered his eyes. I was mad at him for doing that, then mad at myself for being mad. It wasn’t Aaron’s fault we were poor.
A healthy dairy cow came into the ring. Aaron straightened up, and for a few minutes he looked like himself again. The bidding started at forty dollars and climbed to sixty-three. He turned away before the gavel fell. I followed him toward the exit, trying not to look back.
That was when I saw the goats. Thirty-seven of them stood in a filthy pen, ribs showing through their coats. One had a torn ear. Another trembled when it tried to stand. A ranch hand told me they’d been used to clear brush and left to waste away when the owner decided they weren’t worth feeding.
I should have kept walking. Instead, I crouched by the fence and watched the little brown-and-white doe stretch for a purple thistle.
She caught it between her teeth and chewed like it was the best thing she’d had all day. I looked beyond the pen, toward our hillside, with its thistles, wild mustard, and woody brush.
My mother used to say, “A good farmer asks what can thrive on what the land already gives.” I had heard that since I was a girl. For once, it sounded like something I could use. Goats browsed what cattle wouldn’t eat. The does might give milk when they recovered, and I knew how to turn milk into cheese that would keep.
I also knew they could die. They needed water, shelter, and food before they could give us anything. We had no spare money for a long mistake. Still, when the auctioneer called, “Two dollars for the entire lot,” nobody raised a hand.
A rancher called the goats worthless. Briggs laughed and pointed at them. “Maybe those skeletons will finally make you rich!” Then I raised my hand. Aaron grabbed my arm as if I had lost my mind. “Margaret, what are you doing?” he whispered. I didn’t answer him. I couldn’t, not without lowering my hand.
The auctioneer asked if anyone wanted to bid against me. No one did. His gavel fell, and I had spent two dollars of our thirty-one on thirty-seven starving goats. It took four hours to get them home. We borrowed a wagon for the weakest ones, and by sunset the shed was crowded with animals that needed more than we could afford to give them.
Aaron stood in the doorway. “How are we going to keep them alive?” he asked. I looked toward the hillside. The old crop fields were almost bare, but the deep-rooted brush was still there. “We’ve been trying to farm the wrong animals,” I said. He watched me for a while, then went to fix the shed.
We gave the goats clean water and divided our hay into careful portions. I made notes by lantern light: who stood, who ate, who needed the most help. I stayed beside Thistle. Before dawn, she cried out, and I ran barefoot to the shed.
Now I was on the dirt with her head in my lap. Aaron brought the water. I checked her again, felt her swollen udder, and saw the way her sides tightened. “She’s in labor,” I said. Aaron knelt beside me. “Can you help her?” I told him I would try.
The kid was coming wrong. I had never delivered a goat before, but I knew enough not to pull hard or panic. Aaron held the lantern while I worked, stopping when I needed to stop and starting again when Thistle pushed. Her coat smelled sour with sweat and dust. My knees hurt against the packed earth. Then the kid came free, small and wet and making a thin sound.
A doe. Alive.
I rubbed her with a clean cloth while Aaron kept the lantern steady. Thistle lay there breathing hard, but she lifted her head when the kid cried. I made a warm bran mash with water steeped with willow bark and elderberry leaves, the old remedy I knew from home, and got a little into Thistle. Her fever eased by morning. I stayed until I was sure she could hold her head up.
Aaron looked at the kid. “She’s got a loud voice for something so small.” I let out a laugh I didn’t know I had in me. All thirty-seven of the original goats made it through that first night. With the newborn, there were thirty-eight.
Three weeks later, the herd was out on the hillside each morning. At first I followed them, worried they’d find nothing or wander off. They climbed over rocks where a cow could have broken a leg and worked through the scrub oak, wild mustard, woody clover, and thistles. They ate what was already growing there.
The drought kept drying out Briggs’s fields. His cattle lost weight on the short grass, while our goats began to fill out. I don’t mean they turned fat overnight. It was slow. But their coats got smoother, and the does started giving milk. The hillside looked different too. The goats cleared the thick weeds, and sweet native grass began showing along the terraces.
Aaron stopped staring at Briggs’s pastures. He had a job before him now, one that needed doing. He mended the fence and built a better gate while I handled the milking. We didn’t talk much about how close we had come to losing the farm. We knew.
By August, I was milking the does twice a day. Fresh milk was no use to us if we couldn’t sell it before it spoiled in the heat. So I went to Aaron with another idea. I wanted a cool cellar cut into the shaded north side of the hill.
He looked at the slope. “That’s a lot of digging.” I said, “I know.” We had no money to hire help, so we did it ourselves. Aaron dug into the limestone while I hauled out the dirt and lined the space as best I could. It took longer than I planned. Most things did.
I set a copper kettle over a stone fire and made curd from the milk, following what my mother had taught me. I pressed each wheel into a cedar hoop with scrubbed river stones. Then I salted it and wrapped it with lard and wild herbs before taking it into the cellar to age. Some days I worried I was wasting good milk. I kept making the wheels anyway.
The cellar stayed cool while the sun baked the hillside. I turned the cheese and checked it, then turned it again. The smell changed from plain milk to something rich and nutty. By the time I had thirty-two rounds drying on cedar slats, I thought we might have a chance. I didn’t know yet who would buy them.
In mid-August, Howell Briggs rode up to our gate with two hundred dollars in paper bills. He came with a smug smile, like he was doing us a favor. He expected to find us out of feed and ready to sell. Aaron was mending a fence when Briggs arrived. I was coming out of the cellar with a twenty-pound wheel of cheese in my arms.
Briggs looked past me at the hillside. The goats were healthy, their coats glossy in the sun. Thistle was among them, her kid close beside her. Briggs stared at the herd, then at the cheese. “Where did your skeletons go?” he asked.
I set the wheel down. Aaron had come up behind me, but he didn’t speak for me or step between us. I cut a thin slice of cheese on the blade of my knife and held it out to Briggs. He took it. He chewed once, then again.
“They made us rich, Mr. Briggs,” I said. “And our land is no longer for sale.”
He didn’t have much to say after that. He put the two hundred dollars away and rode back down the hill. I watched him go. Then I went back to work.
The first cheese sale went through Caleb Vance, the storekeeper at the mining junction. He sent word that railroad crews needed food that could stand the trip, and the men at the Silverthorne mining camp wanted something better than hard bread. He tasted a piece, asked how long I’d aged it, and bought sixteen wheels. He paid in hard coin.
That first payment covered the county back taxes. A second batch brought in more than ninety dollars altogether. It was more than three dairy cows would have cost us, and enough to buy winter supplies and seed. We cleared the land deed and repaired the roof before the cold set in. We didn’t get rich in the way Briggs meant it, but we stayed on our land.
The goats kept clearing the hillside. The milk kept coming. Aaron no longer looked across the valley wishing he had Briggs’s pasture. One evening he stood beside me on the porch and said, “You saw it before I did.” I told him I had only seen one goat eating a weed. He said, “That was enough.”
At dusk, Thistle led the herd down the slope toward the evening water trough. Her crooked horn showed above the others, and her kid stayed close at her side. Thirty-eight sleek goats moved behind them, their bells chiming softly against the Colorado rock. Aaron stood beside me. I rested my hand on the deed in my pocket and watched them come home.