The phone was warm in my hand when I tagged my husband’s ex in a picture of myself. I’d meant for her to see it. I’d meant for David to see her see it, too.

That was the mean part. I can dress it up as confidence now, but I was trying to make him feel watched.

I know I was wrong. I’m not writing this because I think I handled it well.

There’s a reason I did it, though, and there’s one thing on David’s phone I didn’t know about until he tried to hide it.

He was sitting across from me on the couch when his phone started buzzing. We were both home, and the front door was still unlocked because I’d just come in with a little bunch of flowers I bought for myself. David’s cheeseburger wrapper was folded on the coffee table. My phone was in my hand. Neither of us had said much yet.

He looked down at his screen.

I watched him turn it face down.

Then it buzzed again.

“I thought we were done with this,” he said.

“We haven’t even started.”

He looked at the red dress I still had on. “You’re serious.”

“I’m sitting right here.”

The picture had been up for about twenty minutes. That was all. It was a studio photo, nothing I hadn’t worn before, but I looked different in it.

My back was straight. My hair was done. I wasn’t smiling like I was asking whether it was okay to take up space.

I’d written, “I know how to be beautiful too when I stop making myself small.”

Then I tagged Chloe.

I didn’t put her name in the caption. I didn’t send her a message. I tagged her because that was enough to make sure the picture found its way to her phone.

There. That’s the part I’m ashamed of.

David’s phone buzzed again. He pressed his palm over it.

“Who’s texting you?” I said.

“No one.”

“I can hear your phone.”

“It’s Chloe.”

I held my phone lower in my lap. I didn’t ask him to say more. I wanted him to keep talking, and I wanted to seem like I didn’t care whether he did.

That isn’t a good combination.

A few hours earlier, I’d been on the couch in sweatpants, eating a glazed donut and scrolling.

I wasn’t searching for Chloe. I don’t follow her, and I’m not proud to say I’ve checked her page before. The app put one of her posts in front of me anyway.

She was on a beach in a white dress. The photo was the kind where the person looks like she just happened to be beautiful while standing there. I remember that because I got annoyed at the picture before I even saw the comment.

David had written, “Beautiful.”

One word. A public comment. I sat there with sugar on my thumb, trying to decide if I was allowed to be hurt by nine letters.

I know how stupid that sounds. I’ve read it back to myself, too. But I wasn’t upset because I believed David had never seen a beautiful woman. I was upset because he’d chosen to tell Chloe, where she and everyone else could see it, while I was two rooms away trying to get an old coffee stain out of a cushion.

I called his name.

“David.”

He was eating at the dining table. He said, “Mmm?”

“Did you comment ‘beautiful’ on Chloe’s picture?”

He stopped chewing. Just for a second.

“Oh, please don’t start.”

That was his first answer.

I remember the little wrinkle in the napkin he had in his hand. I don’t know why that stayed with me. I remember it better than what I said back.

“It was one comment,” he said. “You’re making too much of it.”

“If I said that to my ex, would it be nothing?”

His face changed. “Don’t compare it.”

“Why not?”

“Because it’s different.”

“Different how?”

He wiped his mouth. “Chloe’s always been attractive. It doesn’t mean anything.”

I was looking at the comment again while he said this. I heard myself tell him, “You’re right. It doesn’t mean anything.”

I smiled, too. Not because I’d forgiven him. I wanted him to see that I wasn’t going to argue. I wanted him to feel relieved. I wanted him to underestimate me. I know that’s ugly.

I’d told myself I was going to let it go. Then I searched for a photographer.

At first I only meant to look. I found a studio in River North and booked a short session before I could talk myself out of it. I paid for the makeup artist. I rented a red dress that showed more than my usual clothes did. I think I chose it because I couldn’t imagine David describing it as “comfortable.”

When the makeup artist asked what the photos were for, I said, “I’m not sure yet.”

She glanced at me in the mirror. “Birthday?”

“No.”

“Something special?”

“Maybe.”

I didn’t say revenge. I wasn’t brave enough to call it that out loud.

The photographer asked me to look into the lens like I’d just gotten something back. I thought that was a silly direction. Then I looked up and saw my own face in the camera.

I looked like myself. Not the version who’d learned to shrug when David made a comment that bothered me. Not the version who kept a few nicer clothes in the back of the closet because he liked me better in jeans.

I liked the picture. That part was real.

So was the part where I posted it to get at him.

The studio had sent me a gallery link. I picked the calmest picture, not the one where my mouth was open in a smile. I put up the caption, tagged Chloe, and set my phone down.

By the time I was in the car, David had called seventeen times. I didn’t answer any of them. I sat in the back of a rideshare with the flowers on my lap and watched his name come up again.

Then his text came through.

“Delete that right now. You’re making a fool out of me.”

I read it twice. I wanted to tell myself he was embarrassed because I’d tagged Chloe, not because people were seeing me. But the thing is, he had called his ex beautiful in front of everyone. My picture was not private. Somehow one of those things was supposed to be harmless and the other was an attack.

I laughed a little in the car. Not a happy laugh. More like I’d heard the same excuse so many times that my body got there before my mind did.

When I got home, David was waiting in the living room. He had his phone in one hand and his mouth set hard.

“Do you think this is funny?” he said.

“A little.”

“Everybody can see that.”

“That’s usually how a post works.”

“Don’t be cute.”

“I’m not.”

He stood up. I stayed near the coffee table and put the flowers down. One stem had bent in the ride home. I kept trying to make it sit straight in the paper sleeve.

“You’re acting like you’re single,” he said.

I looked at him. “You’re acting like you miss being single.”

He didn’t answer. His phone buzzed once. He looked down at it and turned the screen toward his leg.

I saw the name before he covered it.

Chloe.

I said, “Answer her.”

“It’s nothing.”

“Then answer.”

“I don’t have to answer every time you tell me to.”

“No, you don’t.”

I could’ve stopped there. I knew he was angry, and I knew pushing would make it worse. I kept going anyway because I wanted him to snap. It’s hard to admit that. I wasn’t trying to make things better. I wanted him to be the one who looked unreasonable.

His phone buzzed again.

He glanced at it.

I caught the first line of the message before he turned the screen away. It was enough to make me sit down. I didn’t know what it meant yet, but I knew it wasn’t about my photo.

“What did she say?” I asked.

“Nothing.”

“David.”

“Leave it alone.”

I looked at the phone in his hand. He gripped it so tightly his thumb went flat against the case. I thought about reaching for it, but I didn’t. I’d been the one to drag Chloe into this. I had no right to pretend I was only watching from the outside.

“Did you tell her I copied her?” I asked.

He frowned. “What?”

“Is that what she’s upset about?”

He shook his head. “You tagged her in a picture for no reason.”

“I had a reason.”

“Right. To embarrass me.”

I didn’t answer, because he was right about that.

For a few seconds, the only sound was the phone vibrating against his palm. He silenced it. Then the screen lit again.

I remembered the photo of Chloe on the beach. The white dress. David’s comment. The way he’d said she’d always been attractive, like that closed the subject. I remembered sitting beside him at dinner a week before, when he’d shown me a funny video and leaned his shoulder against mine. I had liked that. I still liked it. That was the bad part, maybe. I kept all of it. The good things didn’t disappear just because I was angry. I could be mad at David and still know the exact way he takes the crust off a sandwich when his mouth is sore. I could wish he’d stop talking about Chloe and still remember that he drove across town for cough drops when I had the flu. I could also know he’d dismissed me without asking why it hurt, and that I’d chosen to answer by turning my marriage into a post for people to react to.

My friends sent hearts and flame emojis. My cousin called me a queen. A coworker wrote “pure elegance.” I liked seeing all of that. I liked it more than I wanted to admit. Then my high school ex commented that I looked stunning, and I left his comment there, too. I could say I didn’t think about how David would read it, but I did. I wanted the comment to sting. I wanted him to feel one small pinch of the thing I’d felt when I saw “Beautiful” beneath Chloe’s picture. The difference was that I knew I was doing it. I planned it. I had the dress, the makeup, the caption, the tag. I’d been careful with the whole thing. People say hurt makes you do things, as if hurt grabs your hand and hits the button for you. It doesn’t. I did that part myself.

David looked at me when I finally stopped talking.

“You’re proud of yourself,” he said.

“No.”

“Then why did you do it?”

“I wanted to see if you cared.”

He let out a short breath. “That’s not how you find out.”

“I know.”

“You could’ve just asked me.”

“I did ask you.”

“You asked about a comment.”

“I asked why you did it.”

“And I told you.”

“You said it didn’t mean anything.”

“That’s the truth.”

I looked down at the flowers. One of them had started to slip out of the paper. I put it back and didn’t look up.

“Then why are you so worried about my picture?” I said.

“Because you tagged her.”

“So that’s what bothers you?”

He didn’t answer right away. His phone buzzed again. I watched his eyes move toward it.

“Answer her,” I said.

He shook his head. “You’re not listening.”

“I’ve been listening for a long time.”

I don’t know if I meant that in the broad way it sounds. I meant I’d been listening to him tell me I was too sensitive. I’d been listening when he said Chloe was just an old friend. I’d been listening to him say he didn’t like public drama, while leaving a public comment on her picture. I’d also been listening to the sound of my own pride, which was saying I could make him feel something if I pressed hard enough.

His phone buzzed again.

This time the message preview showed up before he could turn it over. I saw Chloe’s name and the first few words.

He moved fast. He turned the screen toward his chest.

“Let me see it,” I said.

“No.”

“Why not?”

“It’s private.”

“You said it was nothing.”

“I didn’t say that.”

“You did.”

“I said leave it alone.”

I stood up. He stood up, too, and for a second we were both by the coffee table, close enough that I could smell the mustard on his breath. He looked tired. That made me feel worse, and I hated that it made me feel worse.

“David, I’m not asking to go through your whole phone.”

“You’re asking to read Chloe’s message.”

“She’s already in this.”

“You put her in it.”

“I did,” I said. “I’m not pretending I didn’t.”

He seemed surprised that I agreed. He held the phone tighter, then lowered it again.

“You wanted to make me look bad,” he said.

“I wanted you to feel bad.”

“That’s not better.”

“No.”

The phone buzzed in his hand. Once. Then again.

“Is there something you need to tell me?” I asked.

He looked at the screen and said nothing.

I waited. I’m not good at waiting. I usually fill silence with whatever will get the other person to reassure me. This time I kept my mouth shut because I was afraid the next thing out of him would be something I couldn’t take back.

His phone lit again. David looked at me, then down at the message.

“Don’t,” he said.

“I haven’t done anything.”

“You’re going to make this worse.”

“I already did.”

He rubbed his forehead with his free hand. “I didn’t want Chloe involved.”

“Then why is she texting you?”

“She’s mad.”

“About the picture?”

He didn’t answer.

I held out my hand. “Show me.”

He stood there a moment, then turned the screen so I could read it. His hand was shaking a little. Mine was, too, though I was trying to keep it still.

The message was short. Chloe had not sent me anything. She had not called me. She had written to David.

“David, tell your wife to stop copying me… or I’ll send her the photos you actually begged me for.”

I read it once.

Then I read it again.

I didn’t ask what the photos were. I didn’t have to ask what part of that sentence he wanted to hide. My face must have changed because he reached for the phone and said, “It’s not what you think.”

I took one step back.

“What did you beg her for?”

“It was a long time ago.”

“How long?”

“Before we got married.”

“That’s not what I asked.”

He pressed his thumb against the side of his phone. “I messaged her when we were fighting.”

“Were you fighting about me?”

“Not exactly.”

There it was. That careful little answer. The kind that gives a person a place to stand without giving them anything true.

I sat back down. Not because I was calm. My knees just felt strange, and I didn’t want to let him see that I was having trouble standing.

“What photos?” I said.

“I didn’t ask her to send anything now.”

“That wasn’t my question.”

“She had some old pictures.”

“Of what?”

He looked away.

I wanted him to say it plainly. I wanted him to be kind enough to make the next part simple, though he’d already shown me he wasn’t going to do that.

“Were they private?” I asked.

He shut his eyes for a second. “Yes.”

I felt the room get too quiet, but it wasn’t like a movie. The refrigerator kicked on in the kitchen. The bent flower slid farther down in its paper sleeve. I could see David’s reflection in the dark part of the television screen, standing there with his phone in his hand, looking like a man who had run out of easy answers.

“How many times did you ask?”

“I don’t know.”

“You don’t know?”

“I wasn’t keeping count.”

He sat down across from me. He didn’t reach for my hand. I was glad he didn’t. I think if he had, I would have slapped it away, and I didn’t want to see that version of myself.

“Why didn’t you tell me?” I asked.

“I didn’t think it mattered.”

“She says you begged.”

“I was lonely.”

“That’s your answer?”

“No. I’m trying to explain.”

“You told me she was just attractive. You didn’t tell me you were asking her for private pictures.”

“I didn’t send anything to her.”

“I didn’t ask if you sent anything.”

“I didn’t meet her.”

“I didn’t ask that either.”

He looked at the floor. For once, I didn’t feel like helping him finish his thought.

“I was stupid,” he said.

I thought of the photo shoot. My rented dress, my caption, the way I’d stared into the camera because the photographer told me to look like I’d gotten something back. I had wanted the photo to say I was still here. I’d also wanted it to say something to Chloe. I’d also wanted David to panic. None of those things made what he’d done okay. None of them made me look like the only honest person in the room.

I looked at the phone again. The message had disappeared from the preview, but David was still holding the screen toward me. He could have closed it. He didn’t.

“Did you comment because you wanted her to answer you?” I asked.

“No.”

“Did she answer?”

He didn’t say anything.

I nodded once. I didn’t know what I was agreeing to. Maybe just that there were parts of his life I hadn’t been allowed to see.

He said, “I’m sorry.”

I believed that he was sorry. I didn’t know what for. The photo request, the comment, the lie by omission, the fact that I’d seen it. Maybe all of it. Maybe just the part that was causing trouble now.

“I shouldn’t have tagged her,” I said.

“No.”

“I did it because I wanted to hurt you.”

He looked at me then. “You did.”

“I know.”

The truth sat there between us without fixing anything. I hadn’t apologized for the picture online. I didn’t know if I would take it down. I didn’t know if David and I were done, or if we were just at the part where the old rules stopped working. I only knew that I wasn’t going to tell myself I’d acted out of pure self-respect. It felt good to be looked at. It felt good to see him worried. It felt good right up until Chloe’s message appeared.

David’s phone buzzed again.

I looked at it. He set it on the table, face up this time.

“You can answer her,” I said.

“I don’t want to.”

“That’s your choice.”

He looked toward the front door. It was still open a few inches. I’d left it that way with my hands full of flowers and phone. He started to get up, then stopped like he was waiting for me to tell him what to do.

I didn’t.

The door stayed open, and neither of us reached for it.