Paul was still telling me about a restaurant insurance claim when Victor pulled out the chair across from him and sat down. I’d left my purse on the seat beside me, and I remember thinking I should move it so Victor wouldn’t sit on the strap. That was my first thought. Not what is he doing here, or how did he find us. Just my purse.

I already knew Victor would be there. Not at dinner, exactly. I knew he would step into my evening somehow. I just didn’t know what it would cost me until he did.

That Friday morning, I wore an emerald-green dress to the office. I had dinner plans and wanted to look like someone who had a life after five. Most days I wore black or gray, partly because it was easier and partly because bright colors felt like asking people to notice me.

I’d spent three years as Victor Vasquez’s executive assistant. The company was called Vasquez Atlantic Logistics, which was the respectable name on the letterhead. I knew enough about the other side of the business to keep my questions to myself. Victor trusted me with his calendar, his calls, and the details he didn’t put in writing. I used to think that meant I mattered to him in a way the other employees didn’t.

He was behind his desk when I stopped at the office door. Rain tapped the windows. I had my folder under one arm and my coat over the other.

“Who are you planning to kiss after work in that dress?”

I turned around. For a second I thought I’d misunderstood him.

Victor asked about cargo, drivers, numbers that didn’t match. He didn’t ask who I was kissing. I looked down at my dress, which was modest enough for work and a little nicer than I usually wore.

“I have dinner,” I said.

“With whom?”

“That’s not your business.”

His jaw moved once. I’d seen him sit across from men who were scared of him and barely move a muscle. This was different, which made me less comfortable, not more.

I told him the man’s name was Paul. I said Paul worked in commercial insurance and had a Labrador. I added that Paul called his mother every Sunday, because I was annoyed enough to give Victor more information than he’d earned.

“Sounds dangerous,” he said.

I should’ve left right then. Instead, I waited to see if he’d say anything else. That’s the part I’m embarrassed about. A small, stupid part of me wanted him to ask me not to go.

He only asked if Paul made me happy.

“I don’t know yet.”

Victor nodded and looked back at his paperwork. I left at 5:03, which was exactly when I said I would. I remember that because I checked the clock before I shut the door, like I was proving something.

Paul texted that he was already at the restaurant. He’d arrived early because he was nervous. I smiled at the message on the elevator ride down. That seemed sweet. It seemed ordinary. I had wanted ordinary for a long time.

Paul was waiting at the little restaurant on the Upper West Side when I got there. He stood up too quickly and bumped his knee on the table.

“Good wow?” I asked.

“Very good wow.”

He pulled out my chair. I hated that I compared it to how Victor would’ve reacted. Victor would’ve noticed who was watching the door, how close the next table was, and whether the waiter had been there before. Paul noticed my dress.

That was supposed to be a good thing.

For the first forty minutes, dinner was easy. Paul told me about a client whose restaurant had flooded after a raccoon got into the roof vent. I laughed hard enough to snort a little, then pretended I’d coughed. Paul didn’t make it weird.

He asked about my family, and I told him about my sister in Connecticut and my mother, who thought I worked for a normal shipping company. I didn’t tell him what Victor really did. I didn’t tell him I knew which driver had been killed years earlier, or that Victor sent money to the man’s widow every Christmas. Some things were private. Some things were dangerous. With me, they’d started to feel like the same thing.

Paul asked if my boss was married. I said no. He grinned and said I’d answered fast. I told him to stop fishing, and he said he was only teasing.

Then I felt it. That little prickly feeling between my shoulders. Three years around Victor’s people had taught me to notice when someone was looking too long.

At the bar near the entrance, Luke Barrett sat with a glass of water. Luke ran Victor’s security. He was looking toward our table, not even trying to hide it.

Paul was still talking about a client when I stood up.

“Restroom?”

I took my purse with me. In the hall, I called Luke. He answered on the first ring.

“What are you doing here?”

“Making sure you’re all right.”

“Is that what Victor told you?”

A pause. Then Luke said, “He told me to keep an eye on the room.”

That was not an answer, and Luke knew it.

I told him to leave. He said he couldn’t. I hung up before I said something I couldn’t take back, then washed my hands even though they were clean. The soap smelled like lemon candy. I remember that better than what I said to myself.

I could’ve left through the back. I could’ve called a car and gone home. Instead, I went back to the table, because leaving would’ve looked like fear and I was tired of letting Victor decide what I was afraid of.

Paul looked up when I sat down. He’d stopped talking.

“Is something wrong?”

I said Luke was a coworker. It was a weak lie, and Paul knew it. He asked if he should call someone. I said no. I said I was fine. I said it twice, which was how I knew I wasn’t.

Victor came in about an hour after he’d asked who I planned to kiss. He didn’t look around the restaurant. He came right to our table, pulled out the empty chair, and sat down across from Paul.

I stood halfway up. My purse strap caught under my chair.

“Victor, what are you doing?”

“I need to ask Paul something.”

Paul looked from him to me. He was trying to keep a polite face, but his hands had gone still on the table.

Victor turned to him. “How long have you been reviewing our insurance file?”

I didn’t know what that meant. Paul’s eyes dropped to his water glass. That told me more than his answer did.

“Three weeks,” he said.

The restaurant kept making its usual sounds around us. Silverware. A chair scraping. Somebody laughing by the bar. I could hear all of it, and I still couldn’t make my brain put the words together.

I asked Paul what he was reviewing.

His firm was looking at a commercial policy for Vasquez Atlantic. There’d been a claim tied to a missing shipment, and his job was to check the risk records. He’d seen my name in the company materials because I handled Victor’s calendar and some of the shipping records. He’d realized who I was after we matched on an app.

He said he’d planned to tell me. He hadn’t thought it would matter on a first date.

That was the story he used. It wasn’t even a very good one.

I didn’t know if he’d looked me up before we met. I didn’t know if he’d asked about my work because he liked me or because he needed to understand who had access to what. He said he really did like me. He said he was sorry. I believed both things could be true. That didn’t make either one feel better.

Victor said Paul should’ve disclosed the conflict. Paul said he hadn’t broken any rules. Victor said, “You made it personal.”

I looked at Victor. He was angry, but there was something else under it. He had used my dinner to check on a business problem. Maybe he’d also wanted to see Paul for himself. I couldn’t separate the reasons, and I didn’t think he could either.

Luke was still at the bar. Victor had known where I was because Luke had watched me come in. He’d known who Paul was because somebody had checked him out. Victor had asked who I planned to kiss, then made sure he could sit across from the answer.

The thing I couldn’t get past wasn’t that he’d shown up. It was how familiar it felt. My first impulse had been to move my purse so it wouldn’t be in his way.

Paul apologized again. He said he could leave if I wanted him to. I looked at him and understood that this wasn’t a choice between Paul and Victor. I’d been trying to have one normal evening with a man I barely knew, and I’d let both men turn it into a test I hadn’t agreed to take.

“Don’t make this about protecting me,” I said to Victor.

“I am trying to protect you.”

“You’re trying to control the room.”

For a few seconds, none of us said anything. Victor didn’t deny it. That hurt more than if he’d argued.

I picked up my purse. The strap had a little crease in it from being trapped under the chair. I told Paul I was sorry our date had turned into a meeting. He said he understood. I don’t know whether he did, but he let me walk out by myself.

Victor followed me to the sidewalk. Luke stayed inside. The rain had eased, but the cuffs of my dress were damp from the walk in.

“Natasha,” Victor said.

I stopped. I wanted him to say something plain. I wanted him to say he was jealous, or that he cared, or that he had no right to follow me. Any one of those would’ve been something I could answer.

He said he’d meant what he told me about Paul. He didn’t like him.

“That isn’t the same as caring about me,” I said.

Victor looked down for a moment. “No.”

It was the most honest thing he’d said all night.

I left. I didn’t go home with Paul, and I didn’t go back upstairs to Victor’s office. I took a cab to my apartment and kept my phone face down on the kitchen table. Victor called once. Paul texted once. I answered neither.

Three weeks later, I gave Victor my notice.

I didn’t make a speech. I handed over a folder with the things I’d been responsible for, including the contact list I’d kept in a paper address book since my first year. I didn’t trust a phone to remember anything forever. That probably sounds old-fashioned. My mother still had our home number written on the back of a grocery receipt from 1998, so maybe I got it from her.

Victor read the resignation letter twice. He asked if I’d made up my mind.

“Yes.”

He didn’t ask me to stay. He didn’t say he was sorry. He just signed the form that released me from the company, then set it between us.

I took it to the office manager. I returned my keys. I left the emerald dress in the closet for months without wearing it. Paul and I exchanged a few messages, but we didn’t go out again. He said he was sorry one more time. I told him I knew, and that was all I had.

I still think Victor cared about me. I also think he cared in a way that made room for his fear before it made room for my choice. Maybe I made room for that too, because it felt like being important. I don’t know how to say that without blaming myself, and I’m not fully past the blame.

The last day I worked for Victor, I carried out the paper address book and left my office key on his desk. This time, I didn’t wait to see if he’d ask me to stay.