Toby had his finger on a bank statement that should never have been in that box, and I knew I’d lied to him.
He’d come home for his birth certificate before starting an engineering job. I told him the cedar box was in my bedroom closet. When he came out, he was holding nothing, but he’d stopped looking at me the way he usually did.
I could smell the damp wool of his coat. He asked if I had coffee. I said yes, though I could tell he didn’t want any.
The next morning, he left for Ohio State earlier than he’d planned. His calls stopped a few days later. I kept telling myself he was busy finishing his degree. Then I called him at 8:14 one night, and he answered.
“Grandma, I don’t want to talk to you anymore. Please leave me alone.”
I said his name. He hung up.
I’m Winnie Dunmore. I’m seventy-six, and I raised Toby from the time he was four. I did a wrong thing, and I’m not writing this to make it sound right. I know some people will say I stole from a child. They won’t be wrong. There is a reason I did it, but it doesn’t change what I did.
Toby’s parents, my son Gordon and his wife, Pamela, died in a car crash on an icy road outside Toledo.
I was fifty-eight. Toby was asleep on my couch under my mother’s green afghan when the state trooper came to the door. I remember the little line of drool on his pillow. I remember that because I was trying not to wake him while a man told me his parents weren’t coming home.
I was already widowed. I worked in a high school cafeteria, and I didn’t have a big house or much savings. My sister Beverly said Toby could go live with his aunt in Arizona. She said it was probably better for him to have a younger guardian and a proper bedroom.
I told her, “He’s staying with me.”
I meant it. I also thought meaning it was enough.
I worked the cafeteria during the day and cleaned offices downtown at night. My neighbor, Mrs. Castellano, watched Toby when I was gone. She’d put him to bed, but he’d come back down and curl up under the green afghan.
When I got home, sometimes close to midnight, he’d scoot over and say he’d saved me the warm spot.
I’d sit beside him until my back stopped hurting so much. He’d lean against my arm. Then I’d carry him upstairs, even when he was getting too big for that.
I remember that part with no trouble. I also remember his used Game Boy, which I bought for his tenth birthday because I couldn’t afford the PlayStation he wanted. He thanked me like it was the best thing in the world. I have replayed that thank-you more times than I should.
After the crash, there was money from Gordon and Pamela’s life insurance. I don’t remember the first amount without checking the papers, but it was a little over $148,000. The court set it aside for Toby. I was named guardian, and I had to keep records.
I understood the words. I didn’t understand how tight they were supposed to hold me.
The house needed a roof. Toby needed braces. There were groceries, winter boots, school fees, and a broken furnace that quit in January. My cafeteria pay didn’t cover it all. I had no husband to split bills with, and no one else was coming over with a check.
The first time I took money from the account, I told myself it was for the house Toby lived in. I paid $2,860 for the furnace. That made sense to me. The next time was the roof, then a dental bill. I didn’t ask a lawyer. I didn’t go back to the court. I kept receipts for some things and lost others.
I also took money for things I didn’t need to call his. A car repair. A month when I fell behind on the mortgage. A bill I was embarrassed to tell Beverly about. It wasn’t one big theft with a plan. It was one decision after another, and I kept thinking I’d make it up when things got easier.
Things didn’t get easier.
Toby did well in school. His teachers said he had a mind for math. He got into advanced classes, then worked weekends at a grocery store in high school. He gave me half his pay, which I put in an envelope in my dresser.
I told myself I was saving for him. That part was true. I left his grocery money alone. I needed that fact to count for more than it did.
By then, the insurance account had less than I expected. I don’t know when I first saw the total and decided not to look again. I know I was afraid. I had used money that belonged to him, and I had no clean way to explain it.
Then Toby got accepted to Ohio State for mechanical engineering. I sat at the kitchen table with the letter and cried. He was laughing at me, asking if I was all right. I told him I was proud. I was. I was also thinking about tuition and how I was going to make sure the money didn’t stop him.
A local foundation had a scholarship program. I went in and asked whether they’d set up a memorial scholarship for Gordon and Pamela. I had to put money into it. I used what remained of Toby’s insurance account, along with some savings of my own, and signed the papers.
The award covered tuition, housing, and a few other costs. It had his parents’ names on it. Toby thought people who’d known Gordon and Pamela had put it together. I let him think that.
I could have said it came from the money his parents left him. I could have told him that I’d also spent some of it keeping us afloat. Instead, I let him stare at the award letter and say, “They’re still looking after me.”
I put my arms around him. I told him they were.
That was the part I can’t make smaller. I didn’t just hide the account. I let him feel grateful for something that should have been his. I liked being the person who had figured it out for him. I liked hearing him say I’d made college possible.
I did make it possible. Just not in the way he believed.
For nearly four years, Toby called most evenings. Sometimes he wanted to talk about classes. Sometimes he needed to know how to get a grease spot out of a shirt. He called from the laundry room once because he’d put a red towel in with his white clothes and thought he’d ruined everything.
I told him to separate the load and stop panicking. He laughed. I could hear the machines thumping through the phone. I held on to ordinary calls like that. I didn’t tell myself why.
Before he left for college, he asked me to sit in the front row at graduation. He said it while he was loading a box into his car, like it was nothing. I told him nothing could keep me away.
Then, in his last spring break, he came home for his birth certificate. He needed it for a new job. I pointed him to the cedar box in my closet and went back to the kitchen to finish the dishes.
I heard the lid open. Then nothing.
I don’t know how long he stayed in there. I remember turning off the tap, drying one hand on my pants, and listening. I could have gone in. I didn’t. I thought if I acted normal, he’d ask me whatever he wanted to ask.
When he came out, he asked for coffee. He didn’t ask about the old papers. He didn’t say anything about his parents. He went to bed early.
He left the next morning.
The calls stopped. I sent him a text asking if he’d made it back. He wrote, “Yes.” I asked if he wanted me to send anything he’d forgotten. He didn’t answer.
I called once, then again. I told myself not to be foolish. Finals were close. He had a job lined up. He’d been busy. I still looked at my phone every time it buzzed.
When he finally said not to contact him, I told myself I had to respect that. I lasted two days. I called again and left a message saying I loved him and that he could tell me anything.
He didn’t call back.
I know what he saw. I opened the cedar box after he left and went through it the way I should have years earlier. The folder had bank statements, court papers, and the foundation’s scholarship agreement. I had left them all together because the box had become a place to store anything I didn’t want to deal with.
The statement showed my withdrawals. The total I could prove was $43,879. There may have been more. I can’t say there wasn’t. The scholarship papers showed that the money used to fund his award came from the account his parents had left him.
There was also a note from me, in my handwriting, listing the checks I’d written and why. I’d made it for myself. I had apparently thought a list would make me feel honest.
It didn’t.
I called the foundation and asked them to explain the scholarship to Toby. They said they couldn’t discuss his records with me. I called the attorney who handled the account years earlier. He said I should have asked before using the money and that the records would show what I’d done. I said I knew. I could hear a clock ticking on his end. He told me I could send Toby a full accounting and offer to repay what I’d taken.
I couldn’t repay $43,879. I had some savings, but not that much. I could sell my car, and I could take money out of my retirement account. Even then, I couldn’t make the years of hiding it go away.
I wrote Toby a letter. I started with an explanation about the furnace. I tore that up. I started again with the car repair. I tore that up too. I kept wanting to show him how hard things had been, as if hardship could sign the papers for me.
Finally I wrote what I should have told him years ago: I had used money that belonged to him. I had told myself I was paying for the home and life I gave him. I had also made choices for myself. Then I let him believe the scholarship was a gift from people who loved his parents, when it came from his parents’ own money.
I mailed the bank records and the scholarship agreement with the letter. I didn’t call first. I knew he had asked me to leave him alone, but I thought he deserved the truth without having to drag it out of me.
He texted four days later. He said he’d read it. He said he didn’t want to talk, and he didn’t want me at graduation.
I started to write that I had promised I’d be there. I deleted it. The promise had been mine to make, not his to keep for me.
I sold my car that summer and sent Toby $18,000. It wasn’t the full amount. I wrote that I’d send more when I could. He didn’t answer. I can’t tell if he thinks that was too little or if he doesn’t want to think about it at all.
He graduated. I learned that from a cousin who saw the ceremony online. I wasn’t in the front row. I wasn’t in the building. I watched the screen from my living room with the green afghan folded beside me.
I didn’t see Toby walk across the stage clearly. The camera kept moving. I could hear his name, though. I recognized the way he paused before he said thank you to the person handing him the folder. He used to do that when he was little, before he answered a teacher.
I still have the envelope with my ticket request in it. I never sent it. I had saved the warm spot for myself for eighteen years, and somewhere along the way I decided that meant I could take up more room than he’d given me.
The scholarship that got Toby through college came from the $104,121 left in his parents’ account. I used $43,879 of it before I made the award.