Curtis was cutting our anniversary cake into pieces too small for anyone to complain about. He always does that. He’d just handed a slice to my brother Nolan when Nolan lifted his glass and said I’d settled for the first guy who asked.
Everybody at the table laughed a little. Not because it was funny. Because we’d heard some version of it so many times that we knew how to get past it.
I set a cassette beside Nolan’s plate.
He looked at the label, and his smile went away.
I’d spent the afternoon telling myself I wasn’t going to make a scene. I’d even practiced saying, “We can talk about it later.” But there I was, with our kids watching and the cake still sitting open on the counter.
I’d found the tape in Dad’s garage while I was helping Nolan sort things out. The label had Dad’s handwriting on it, just one word: “Saturday.” It took me a while to work out which Saturday he meant.
That’s the part I’m getting to.
Nolan and I grew up in a mining town in West Virginia. He was four years older than me and acted like he’d been hired to keep an eye on everything I did. Who I went out with. How late I stayed. Whether I called home.
Dad was the same way, only louder. He could be funny when he wanted to be.
He could also make a room go quiet by setting down his coffee cup too hard. I learned to keep track of small things, like whether his truck was in the driveway and whether his keys were on the kitchen counter.
I called that being careful. It took me years to call it fear.
I met Curtis at a church picnic when I was 22. He worked maintenance at a school and had a habit of keeping a pencil behind his ear. He was steady, not showy. When he asked me to marry him, he didn’t make a speech. He said, “I’d like to build a life with you, if you want that.”
I wanted it.
Nolan didn’t.
He told me I was rushing. He said Curtis had no idea what he was getting into. At the time, I thought he meant Dad. I took Nolan aside one night and asked him what he was really mad about.
He shrugged. “You’re leaving. That’s all.”
Then he said, “Don’t make me the bad guy when you stop coming around.”
I remember that because it sounded so unfair. I told him I wasn’t leaving him. I was getting married.
I don’t think I understood the difference yet.
Our wedding was small. Dad wore a brown suit and spent most of the day making jokes about the food. Nolan stood beside me in the pictures. He even danced with me once, though he kept one hand stiff at my back. I remember thinking we’d made it through the worst of his fussing.
That was wrong, though I didn’t know it then.
For years, Nolan had a way of finding one small thing about Curtis to pick at. If Curtis brought a pie, Nolan said he’d bought it at the store. If Curtis helped Dad carry something, Nolan said he was trying too hard.
When Curtis fixed the loose latch on Dad’s shed, Nolan said, “Look at him, earning his keep.”
Curtis usually just kept working.
I told myself that was the decent thing to do. I also told myself I was keeping the peace. Those two things are not always the same, but I acted like they were.
When Nolan got going, I’d say, “That’s enough.” Not very firmly. More like I was reminding him there were other people at the table.
Curtis would glance at me, then look down at his plate. I knew what that look meant. I just hated being the person who made everyone uncomfortable by naming what Nolan had done.
So I didn’t name it.
At Christmas, Nolan would ask Curtis whether he’d finally found a job with better hours, even though Curtis had worked the same school schedule for years. At Dad’s birthday, he’d say, “Must be nice, marrying into a family with a house.” Curtis had paid his share of our bills since the first year. Nolan knew that.
I would bump Nolan’s foot under the table. He’d grin and say, “What? I’m kidding.”
Curtis never laughed. I can still picture him folding his napkin into a narrow strip, then folding it again. I knew he was hurt, and I let Nolan call it a joke because that was easier for me than telling my brother to stop.
Dad died in 2019. After that, Nolan and I had to clear the garage, which was full of tool boxes, old paint cans, and things Dad had been meaning to fix since the late eighties. Curtis came with me because he knew which tools were useful and which ones belonged in the scrap pile.
Nolan didn’t like that.
“You don’t have to bring him for every little thing,” he said.
“He knows his way around a garage,” I said.
“I know my way around Dad’s garage.”
I could’ve answered him. I could’ve told him Curtis was helping because he loved me, not because he wanted to take over. Instead, I picked up a box of old Christmas lights and carried it outside.
That was what I did then. I moved the small thing out of the way and hoped the bigger one would settle down.
The tape was in a drawer beneath a stack of manuals. It was a little cassette, brown label, Dad’s square handwriting. I put it in my pocket. I didn’t know why. It looked like something I should keep.
Later that week, I found an old cassette player in a box of his things. I put the tape in, heard the click, and took it back out before I pressed play.
I kept telling myself I’d listen when I had time. Then I told myself I’d listen when Nolan was there. Then I said I didn’t need to listen at all.
I had my reasons. Some were better than others.
On our 25th anniversary, Curtis booked a table at a little restaurant near home. Our daughter and son came, and Nolan came because I’d invited him. I know that sounds foolish. I wanted one night where nobody had to choose sides. I wanted to prove we could all sit together like a family.
The food was good. Curtis ordered the same thing he ordered on our first date. I can’t remember what I got. I remember the bread had a hard, shiny top and left flakes on the white tablecloth.
Nolan was in a good mood at first. He asked our son about work and told our daughter she’d gotten pretty good at making pies. For a while, I let myself think he might be there to celebrate us.
Then Curtis cut the cake.
Nolan lifted his glass. “To Loretta, who settled for the first guy who asked.”
He smiled at Curtis. “You got lucky, buddy.”
There it was again. I felt my face warm, but I still didn’t speak right away. I looked at Curtis. He’d set the cake knife down carefully, like it might break if he let go too fast.
Our daughter stopped chewing.
I could hear Dad’s garage door rattling in my head, though we weren’t anywhere near it. That old sound. I used to know whether Dad was home by the way the door came down.
I put my hand in my purse and touched the cassette.
I’d brought it with me without deciding to bring it. I guess some part of me already knew I was tired of pretending.
I took it out and set it by Nolan’s plate.
His eyes went to the label. His fingers stopped on the stem of his glass.
“What’s that?” he said.
“Something I found in Dad’s garage.”
He looked at me. “You listened to it?”
“I did.”
Curtis didn’t move. Our kids looked from Nolan to me. I could have stopped there. I could have put the tape away and told Nolan we’d talk privately.
Instead, I said, “It’s Dad talking to you the night before my wedding.”
Nolan’s mouth tightened. “You shouldn’t have listened to that.”
I heard myself say, “Why not?”
He didn’t answer.
I’d brought the player too. It was old and had a crack by the button, but it still worked. I hadn’t planned to use it at dinner. I had planned to talk to Nolan first. I’m telling the truth, but I know how it sounds.
I put the cassette in.
Nolan reached across the table. “Loretta, don’t.”
I moved the player away from him. My hand shook enough that I pressed the wrong button once. Then the tape began to turn.
There was a little hiss. A scrape, like a chair moving over concrete. Dad’s voice came through, quieter than I remembered it.
He said my name.
Then he said Nolan’s.
I heard Nolan answer, but I couldn’t make out the words. Dad spoke again. He sounded tired. Not angry. That made it worse somehow.
He said I’d been afraid of him for years. He said he knew I’d been afraid. He said he’d grabbed me hard enough to leave marks when I was 17, and that I’d told the family I’d walked into a door.
I hadn’t thought about that in decades. I remembered the bruise. I remembered wearing a sweater in warm weather. I remembered Dad apologizing the next morning and saying I’d made him mad.
I had tucked the rest away so well I’d almost convinced myself it wasn’t part of my life.
The tape kept going.
Dad told Nolan I was leaving because I needed to. He told him not to come after me and not to tell me what Dad had said. Nolan asked something I couldn’t hear. Dad answered in a flat voice that made the whole table feel smaller.
Then came the line I can’t get out of my head.
“Tell her that man took her away. Better she blames him than comes back to me.”
The tape clicked off.
Nobody spoke for a few seconds. I could hear the old player’s motor running, even though the tape had ended.
Nolan sat with both hands on the table. He didn’t look at Curtis. He looked at the cassette.
I asked, “You knew?”
He rubbed his thumb along the edge of his plate. “I knew what Dad did.”
“Did you know he said thatHe nodded. “I knew he was going to say it. I asked him to.”
Nolan said he’d been scared I’d go back to Dad after the wedding. He thought if I blamed Curtis for taking me away, I’d stay gone. Then Dad died, and Nolan kept acting like Curtis had stolen me, because admitting why he’d started would mean admitting how long he’d let the lie stand.
“I was mad at him,” Nolan said. “And I was mad at myself.”
Curtis didn’t tell him it was all right. I didn’t either. Nolan’s cake sat untouched beside the cassette, and nobody asked me to cut another slice.