I told Mara our baby wasn’t my responsibility, then I showed up after he was born and saw my mother’s name on his bracelet.
I know how that sounds. I said it anyway. I was scared, but I also wanted to hurt her before she could hurt me. Both things can be true.
I didn’t go to the hospital when Mara went into labor. I was at my friend Denny’s apartment, sitting on the edge of his couch with my boots still on, pretending I hadn’t heard my phone buzz six times. The call that finally got through came from Dr. Lyle.
“Your son’s here,” he said.
I said, “I can’t do this.”
He didn’t argue. He just said, “Then come see what you’re walking away from.”
I’m not proud of what I did. I’m also not going to pretend I was some helpless man dragged along by circumstances. I made choices. I kept making them, even when they got ugly.
Mara and I met when I was thirty and she was twenty-eight. I worked maintenance for the county, mostly fixing pumps and electrical panels. She worked at a dental office in Poughkeepsie. She had this habit of saving the paper sleeves from coffee cups to use as bookmarks, which I used to tease her about. There were always three or four on the end table, even when the books were long gone.
Our marriage wasn’t perfect, but it was mostly ordinary. We ate dinner late because I got home late.
She’d leave a plate in the microwave and write “DON’T FORGET” on a sticky note, though I never forgot. I knew what her cough sounded like when she was actually sick, and she knew I hated the sound of the neighbor’s leaf blower before seven in the morning.
That sort of thing. Not a grand romance. A life.
Then I got laid off from a contractor job I’d been counting on. I told Mara I was fine. I wasn’t. I got mean about small things, and she got quiet. I’d come home and find her sitting at the kitchen table with the bills spread out, and I’d ask why she had to make everything look so bad.
She’d say, “Because it is bad.”
I’d tell her she didn’t have to talk to me like I was an idiot.
She’d say, “I’m trying to talk about the bills.”
I didn’t want to talk about the bills. I wanted to feel like the man I’d been before I got laid off.
I wanted her to look at me like I was still useful. Instead of saying that, I picked fights.
By the time we separated, I’d been sleeping in the spare room for six weeks. I remember the date because Mara had marked it on the calendar for a dental appointment and I crossed out the wrong day with a black pen. That’s the kind of detail I remember. I don’t remember what I said when she told me she was done.
I remember the pen.
The divorce was finalized in March. We didn’t have kids. We split the furniture without much trouble. I took the old television and she kept the kitchen table. That table had a burn mark from when I set a pan down without a trivet. She said she wanted it anyway.
I should have known there was still something between us from the way she kept answering my calls. Not warmly, exactly. Just answering.
In June, she texted me: “I need to tell you something.”
We met in the parking lot outside a grocery store because neither of us wanted to go to the other’s place. She had one of those paper coffee sleeves in her hand. I noticed because it was a weird thing to bring to a parking lot. I didn’t ask about it.
“I’m pregnant,” she said.
I asked how far along.
“Almost nine weeks.”
I did the math in my head. I was still sleeping at the house until the first week of April. We’d had sex once, after the divorce papers were signed but before I moved my stuff. I remembered it because she’d asked if I wanted to stay for breakfast and I’d said I had errands.
I said, “Are you sure?”
Her mouth got tight. “Yes.”
I know what a lousy question that was. I asked it anyway.
She said she wasn’t asking me for anything. She just didn’t want me hearing it from somebody else.
I looked down at the coffee sleeve in her hand. She was rubbing the seam with her thumb, back and forth. That little movement annoyed me, and I hate that I remember that too.
I said, “I can’t be tied to you again.”
She said, “This isn’t about us being tied together.”
I told her I needed time.
She said, “You’ve had time.”
I drove away before she could say anything else. I called Denny on the way home and told him she might be trying to pull me back in. He said, “She’s pregnant, Cal. That’s not a trick.” I told him he didn’t know what she was like.
He did know. He’d been at our wedding.
For a few weeks, I texted Mara every couple of days. I asked if she’d been to the doctor. I asked what the due date was. She answered, but she didn’t give me much. Then I got a temporary job doing maintenance at a hotel and started seeing Janice, a woman I knew from the contractor office.
Janice had just turned thirty-five. She was easy to be around because she didn’t know the old version of me. I could tell her I was starting over, and she didn’t ask what I’d done wrong the first time.
Mara noticed. Of course she did.
“You’re seeing somebody,” she said over the phone.
“I didn’t say that.”
“You don’t have to.”
I was angry at her for finding out. That makes no sense, but I was.
“Don’t make this into something it isn’t,” I said.
“What is it, then?”
“I don’t know.”
She went quiet.
Then she said, “I’m not asking you to love me again. I’m asking you to act like this is your child.”
I said, “I don’t know that it is.”
The words were out before I could dress them up. I heard how they sounded. She heard it too.
“Fine,” she said.
I tried to take it back. Not the doubt. Just the way I’d said it.
“Mara, I didn’t mean, ”
“You did.”
She hung up.
I didn’t call back that night. I told myself she needed space. Really, I was relieved not to have to talk about it.
That’s what I mean when I say I knew what I was doing. I knew I was choosing the easiest thing in front of me. I just kept calling it something else.
In August, she sent me a photo of an ultrasound printout. No message with it. The picture was grainy, with a little white shape in the middle. I stared at it longer than I meant to. I could not tell what I was looking at, but I could see a hand, or maybe a foot. I zoomed in and the image got worse.
I typed, “Is everything okay?”
Then deleted it.
I typed, “Looks good.”
Deleted that too.
I sent, “Thanks for letting me know.”
She replied, “It’s not a work update.”
I put my phone face down on the table and went outside to smoke, even though I’d quit two years earlier. I bought a pack at the gas station and smoked three in the parking lot. Then I threw the rest away. I went back the next day and bought another pack.
My sister Bev knew about the pregnancy by then. She said I was being a coward. I told her I didn’t need a lecture from somebody who’d been married three times.
She said, “I’m not lecturing you. I’m telling you what you look like.”
I told her she could keep her opinion to herself.
She didn’t. Bev has never been good at that.
In September, Mara called to say she’d picked a name if the baby was a boy. She said it like she was reading a grocery list.
“Arthur.”
I knew that name. My mother was named Arlene, but everybody called her Artie. She died when I was twenty-one. Mara had met her once, when we were dating. My mother had been sick then and didn’t say much. Mara brought her a little cup of applesauce because she thought the hospital food looked awful.
“Why Arthur?” I asked.
“Because I like it.”
I wanted her to say she was naming him after my mother. I wanted that and also didn’t want it, because then I’d have to admit there was still some part of our life she was carrying that I’d thrown away.
I said, “That’s a strange choice.”
“Okay.”
“I’m just saying.”
“I heard you.”
She ended the call.
I didn’t ask her to change it. I didn’t tell her I liked it either.
By October, Janice and I were spending most weekends together. I told her the baby might not be mine. She asked if I had any reason to think that.
I said, “We were divorced.”
She said, “That’s not what I asked.”
I told her Mara had moved on before the papers were final. That wasn’ttrue. Mara hadn’t moved on before the divorce. I knew that, and I’d said it to make my story sound better.
When Dr. Lyle called, he told me Mara had delivered a boy. I got there about twenty minutes later. He was holding the baby, crying quietly, and Mara looked at me like I was a bill she’d already paid.
“What’s wrong?” I asked.
Dr. Lyle turned the baby so I could see his face. “Your mother had that same little mark by her ear,” he said. “I was her doctor. I’m sorry. I just didn’t expect to see it again.”
The hospital bracelet said Arthur. Mara had named him after my mother, even after everything I’d said. She let me hold him for less than a minute, then asked me to leave. I did. The next week, I signed the papers to establish paternity. My name went on his birth record. It didn’t put me back in the room.
I still have the photo Dr. Lyle took before I left. Arthur’s name is printed on the bracelet. Under it, in Mara’s handwriting, she’d added “Artie.”