Reads

1,409 Articles

Latest in Reads

READS 14 min

My granddaughter called me on a Tuesday night and said, “Grandma, please take down the video of my dance.” I was sitting at the kitchen table with my phone propped against a jar of flour. The video had been up for three days. It showed sixteen-year-old Maya finishing her school performance in a blue costume, breathing hard and smiling while the audience clapped. I had watched it at least twenty times. “What’s wrong with it?” I asked. “I don’t want it on Facebook.” “I thought you liked the video.” “I do. I just don’t want everybody seeing it.” “Everybody can’t see it. I only shared it with friends.” “You have over six hundred friends.” The number surprised me. I had never thought of the people on my page as an audience. They were old coworkers, cousins, neighbors from our street, women from church, and people who had been kind to me after my husband died. I had posted the video because I was proud of Maya. I had not thought about what it meant to have six hundred people watch her. “I can change the setting,” I said. “I want you to delete it.” Her voice was steady, not disrespectful. That made it hard to dismiss her as being dramatic. “Did someone say something?” “Can you just take it down?” I heard a door shut in the background. Her mother, my daughter Kelly, came on the phone. “Mom, please remove it tonight.” “I’m asking what happened.” “It doesn’t matter. Maya asked you to take it down.” “I’m her grandmother. I’m allowed to be proud of her.” “You can be proud without posting her.” The sentence stung. “I didn’t know this was going to be a problem.” “It is a problem now. Please listen to her.” I ended the call without saying goodbye. Then I watched the video again. Maya turned toward the lights, found her mark, and finished the last eight counts. In the corner of the frame, two girls in the back row were laughing. I had not noticed them before. I told myself that was not enough reason to delete the whole thing. Then I heard Maya’s voice: I don’t want everybody seeing it. I removed the video. Before I went to bed, I opened the album on my phone where I kept pictures of Maya. There were hundreds: a toothless grin at kindergarten, a snowman with one eye, a school play where she had been a tree. I had once mailed those pictures to my sister and written the date on the backs. Nobody else saw them unless I handed over the envelope. When Maya was twelve, she had asked me not to post a picture of her in a bathing suit. I remembered telling her that only family could see my page. I had believed that answered her concern. It did not. She had been trying to explain that the picture belonged to her, and I had answered with a setting on my phone. I scrolled past the old photos and noticed how many had been posted without asking. I had not shared anything unkind or embarrassing on purpose. That did not mean she had agreed to have her childhood turned into a public scrapbook. I felt ashamed, then defensive, then ashamed of being defensive. My husband used to say I remembered the day better than anybody because I kept the pictures. He was right about the remembering. He was not right that the pictures belonged to me alone. I could still keep them in an album, print them, write dates on the backs, and show them when Maya wanted to see them. I did not have to publish them to make them real.

My granddaughter called me on a Tuesday night and said, “Grandma, please take down the video of my...