8:00 Sunday morning. Dad’s text was still open on my phone when I pulled into Amanda’s driveway.
“Come to your sister’s house right now, I stayed the night and prepared a little ‘surprise’ for her. Bring coffee.”
I’d read it six times on the drive. The last part was underlined in my head. Bring coffee. Dad wasn’t a prank person. At least, I hadn’t thought he was.
The day before, I’d turned twenty-one at Amanda’s house. I’d been looking forward to it all week. There was barbecue in the backyard, cake with too much frosting, and Lily running around the lawn with a paper plate balanced on her head. She’s seven, and she’s always had a big idea ready before the last one is finished.
I love that about her. I love her, period.
I’d brought my sedan because it’s the car I saved for over two years to buy. I worked double shifts at the restaurant and the clothing store, then put every extra dollar toward it. It’s used, nothing fancy, but it starts every time. I still notice that when I turn the key.
At the party, Lily kept asking to sit in it. Amanda told her not to touch the buttons. Lily put both hands behind her back and leaned in to look anyway.
“Your car is so grown-up,” she told me.
I laughed. “It’s mostly just good at getting me to work.”
That was one of the last normal things I remember from the afternoon.
Around six, I was walking down Amanda’s driveway with my keys in my hand when I saw the paint. Thick, bright streaks covered the driver’s side, from the front fender to the back door. There were lopsided flowers, neon hearts, and smiling stick people. Four half-empty cans of exterior house paint sat in the grass by my front tire.
I stopped. I had no smart thought. I just stared at the driver’s door, where a purple flower had run down toward the handle.
Lily came bouncing over with a brush in her hand and paint on her overalls.
“Surprise! I made your car beautiful for your birthday, Auntie Jess!”
Her face was so proud that I felt bad before I even said anything.
That’s the part I hate admitting. I was angry. I was also trying to make sure she didn’t see it.
I bent down and gave her a careful hug around the paint on her sleeves.
“Wow, sweetheart. That’s very creative. Thank you for thinking of me.”
She grinned and took off toward the porch. I waited until she was out of earshot, then asked Amanda to come over by the garage.
I kept my voice low. I didn’t want Lily hearing me, and I didn’t want the whole party turning to look.
“Amanda, this is exterior paint. I don’t know what it’ll do to the finish if I try to get it off myself. I need a professional. Could we split the bill?”
She looked at me like I’d asked her to pay for my whole car.
“Are you seriously asking me for money right now?”
“Yes,” I said. “Lily was unsupervised with house paint. I’m not mad at her. I just can’t pay thousands of dollars for this by myself.”
Amanda crossed her arms. Her voice got louder.
“She’s a seven-year-old child, Jessica. What is wrong with you? It was a birthday gift from the heart. Don’t you love your niece?”
“Of course I do. That’s why I didn’t yell at her.”
I pointed at the paint, then wished I hadn’t. Amanda’s face tightened.
“You are so materialistic it makes me sick. It’s just a stupid piece of metal. If you hate my daughter and her creativity so much, don’t ever come to my house again. In fact, stay away from Lily altogether.”
I looked past her and saw Dad by the patio screen door. He’d heard all of it. His jaw was set, but he didn’t step in.
I wish I could say I said something sharp back. I didn’t. Amanda went inside and slammed the door. I got into my car and drove home with wet paint still shining on the doors. I cried at a red light, which was embarrassing even though nobody knew me there.
At home, I tried to wipe a streak off the handle with an old dish towel. It smeared. I stopped before I made things worse, rinsed the paint off my fingers, and went to bed.
I didn’t sleep much. I kept thinking about Amanda’s last line. Stay away from Lily. It sounded like a threat she’d take back in the morning. It also sounded like she meant it.
Then Dad’s text came at eight.
I bought two coffees on the way. When I got to Amanda’s, Dad was waiting on the porch. He took one cup and winked at me.
“Just come inside,” he said.
I was already wondering if he’d talked Amanda down. Then I heard her from the living room.
“What did you do?”
She wasn’t yelling yet. She sounded more like she’d walked into the wrong house.
I rounded the corner. The white sofa was almost impossible to miss. It was the one Amanda had bought after she renovated the living room, the custom Italian linen one she told everyone had cost three thousand dollars. Purple and yellow handprints covered the cushions. A line of green paint crossed one arm. There were rainbows and big painted dogs on the cream wall behind it.
Lily stood by the coffee table with a roller brush dripping onto the floor. Dad had a green dab on his nose.
Amanda had both hands in her hair.
“Dad! Were you watching her? That’s custom linen. You can’t wash acrylic paint out of linen!”
Dad took a slow sip of coffee. He looked at me once, then back at Amanda.
“After what you said yesterday, I figured you meant it,” he said. “Lily woke up at six wanting to paint again. I gave her the washable craft paint and said to make her mommy’s favorite room as beautiful as Auntie Jess’s car.”
Amanda stared at him. For a second, she didn’t seem to know which person to be mad at first.
“Are you insane? Do you know what it costs to replace this couch?”
Dad set his coffee down.
“Are you seriously upset about money right now? She’s a child, Amanda. What is wrong with you? Don’t you love your daughter?”
He used her exact words. I looked at the sofa, then at Amanda. I knew she could have argued back. I think she wanted to. Her mouth opened, then closed.
Dad’s voice wasn’t playful anymore.
“Jessica was kind to Lily. She asked you to split the cost of damage you were responsible for as her parent. You called her materialistic and told her to stay away from her niece.”
Amanda’s shoulders dropped. That was all. No big scene. Just her arms falling to her sides.
“I didn’t mean that,” she said.
I looked at her. “You said it.”
“I know.” She glanced at the sofa. “I panicked.”
Dad reached into his shirt pocket and pulled out a business card. It was for Mike’s Auto Body downtown, where he’d called his longtime friend the night before.
“Mike says they can get the house paint off for six hundred dollars if Jess brings the car in this morning,” Dad said. “Before it cures in the sun. Amanda, you’re paying the full amount. I’ll help you get the sofa cleaned, but that bill is yours.”
Amanda looked back at him.
“You already called Mike?”
“I did.”
“You’re making me pay for this couch, too?”
“No. You’re paying for your couch. That’s different.”
It was blunt. It was also fair.
Lily was still holding the roller. Amanda looked at her, then at the paint on the sofa. Her voice softened.
“Lily, put the roller down, please.”
Lily did. She wasn’t crying. She just looked confused.
“I made it pretty,” she said.
“I know you were trying to,” Amanda told her. “But we don’t paint on furniture or cars. We paint on paper.”
I didn’t know what to say, so I took a sip of coffee. It was too hot. I held the cup anyway.
Amanda got her phone from the pocket of her robe. She made the transfer while Dad watched. My phone chimed. Six hundred dollars.
“Jess,” Amanda said. She looked right at me this time. “I’m sorry. I saw that sofa bill coming, then you said thousands of dollars, and I just got scared. I shouldn’t have taken it out on you.”
She swallowed.
“I know you love Lily. I know you weren’t mad at her.”
I wanted to tell her the whole thing was fine. It wasn’t. I wanted to tell her I didn’t care about the car. I did. I needed it to get to work, and I’d worked for it. So I just said, “Thank you for apologizing.”
Then I added, “And the purple handprints do bring out the natural light.”
Dad snorted into his coffee. Amanda actually laughed, although she wiped her face right after, like she was annoyed with herself for almost crying.
The sofa had to be treated by an upholstery cleaner. Some paint came out, but a faint shadow stayed on one cushion. Amanda paid the cleaner herself. Dad moved the leftover exterior paint cans onto a high shelf in the garage and locked the cabinet.
We left for Mike’s at about ten. Amanda came along to see the car, and Lily stayed home with her. At the shop, Mike looked over the paint and told us not to touch it again. He had two guys start on it right away.
I sat in the office with Dad and Amanda. There was a little bowl of peppermints on the counter. I took one and let it sit in my mouth while Amanda looked down at her hands.
“I was embarrassed,” she said. “I’d just spent too much on the renovation. I didn’t want to say that out loud, so I made you sound like the bad one.”
“I’m not made of money either,” I said. “I’ve been picking up shifts to pay for that car.”
“I know. I should’ve remembered.”
The paint came off before the afternoon sun could bake it in. Mike’s crew stripped it carefully and buffed the clear coat. When I saw my sedan roll out, clean again, I checked the driver’s door twice. It was smooth. The purple streak was gone.
Amanda covered the six hundred dollars. She didn’t bring up splitting it later, and I didn’t offer. Dad had been right about that part.
The two of us drove back to her house with Dad following behind. Lily was waiting in the living room. The sofa had a light shadow on one cushion, and she seemed to notice that Amanda was being careful around it.
Amanda had set up a big paper easel on the floor.
“You can paint on this,” she told Lily. “Not the couch. Not the car. Just the paper.”
Lily looked at me. “Can I paint you a birthday picture?”
“Sure,” I said. “I’ll put it on my fridge.”
She started with a purple flower. This time, the paint stayed on the paper.
My car was parked beside Amanda’s driveway, clean and shining. Inside, I stood beside my sister and watched Lily work. Amanda clapped when Lily added a yellow sun. I did too.
That afternoon, nobody said stay away. We said where the paper was, where the paint belonged, and who was going to help clean up. It wasn’t a perfect fix for everything Amanda and I had said. But when Lily held up her picture, Amanda’s hand found mine on the back of the couch, and she left it there.